Makkah, Saudi Arabia: Is the Holiest City also the Most Deadly City?

makkah

For many muslims around the world their prayers are met if they get to visit Makkah before they die. Makkah is the Utopia of muslims and is one of the most holiest cities in Saudi Arabia as well as the world. For those not familiar, only muslims may visit Makkah and boundaries identifying the protective or muslim-only area surround the city.

Makkah is home to the Ka’aba Shrine and the Grand Mosque (Haram). Approximately three million pilgrims from all corners of the world come to Makkah each year to perform Hajj, which is one of the five pillars of Islam. The rest of the year Makkah remains active with visitors as well who come to perform Umrah (like a shortened or lesser version of Hajj).

Hajj is carefully controlled by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and a resident from a country outside of the Kingdom cannot just randomly decided “Oh, Hajj starts next week, I think I’ll go to Mecca.” Instead the pilgrims (hajjis) need to apply and register to perform Hajj through an Agency which in turn makes the arrangements for the pilgrims to have accommodation in Meena which is a fiberglass tent city where the majority of all pilgrims stay. On the other hand, there are indeed others from both outside the Kingdom and from within who do come to Makkah during Hajj time and perform Hajj independently and not as part of an organized group.

The Government of Saudi Arabia wishes to control Hajj and the influx of pilgrims for a variety of reasons. Security is naturally a top concern. During Hajj the population of Makkah expands by approximately 3 million people which makes an impact on multiple levels for the area. In addition to the pilgrims, there are additional security forces and paramedics dispatched to Makkah.

The congregation of so many people from different parts of the world in unavoidably overcrowded conditions within a confined area for a short period of time presents many public health challenges. The combination of physical exertion, overcrowding and any pre-existing health conditions such as diabetes, heart disease, chronic chest conditions, renal and liver disease favor local and possibly international spread of communicable diseases, including meningococcal infections, influenza, tuberculosis and gastrointestinal infections.

 

So what do the Saudi authorities do towards preventing spread of disease and infections? To begin with, pilgrims must go through a series of requisite inoculations before arriving in the Kingdom. The Eurosurveillance web site provides excellent detail as follows:

 

The Saudi authorities take these challenges very seriously and continually review arrangements to improve the pilgrims’ environment. Pilgrims also need practical pre-travel advice and appropriate immunisations in their home countries. Vaccination requirements and advice have been issued by the Saudi Ministry of Hajj for the most serious communicable disease risks [3]:

Meningococcal meningitis
All Hajj pilgrims are now required to submit proof of vaccination with the quadrivalent vaccine against meningococcal meningitis types A, C and W135Y as part of the Hajj visa application to Saudi Arabia. This vaccine should have been received not more than three years and not less than ten days before travel to Saudi Arabia, and should be recorded in a vaccination book showing the traveller’s full name [3].
Children over three months and under two years of age may not be adequately protected by a single dose of meningococcal meningitis ACW135Y vaccine. It is therefore recommended that two doses of vaccine are given to this age group with an interval of three months.
Chemoprophylaxis against meningococcal infection will also be given to all people arriving into Saudi Arabia from countries in the African meningitis belt in order to lower the meningitis carrier rate among them. These countries are listed by the World Health Organization [4]. Ciprofloxacin tablets (500mg) will be given to adults, rifampicin to children, and a ceftriaxone injection to pregnant women [4].

Polio
All travellers to Saudi Arabia are advised to ensure their polio vaccination is up to date. Travellers whose last dose of polio was more than ten years ago should receive a booster, using the trivalent tetanus, diphtheria and polio vaccine. For infants and children up to 15 years of age, a polio vaccination certificate is required as part of the visa application for Saudi Arabia, regardless of whether this is for Hajj or not. The certificate of vaccination should have been issued not more than three years and not less than 10 days before the planned arrival date in Saudi Arabia [3].

Children over 15 years of age should present proof of the same vaccinations requested for adults.

Additionally, irrespective of previous vaccination history, all travellers under 15 years of age, arriving from polio-affected countries, will also receive oral polio vaccine on entry to Saudi Arabia. The WHO considers the following countries to be polio-affected (as of 4 October 2006):

• Countries with ongoing transmission wild poliovirus: Afghanistan, India,
• Countries with ongoing transmission poliovirus: Angola, Bangladesh, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Ethiopia, Namibia, Nepal,
• Countries with recent circulation poliovirus: Indonesia, Sudan, Yemen.

The Ministry of Health of Saudi Arabia advises that all travellers from Afghanistan, India, Pakistan and Nigeria, regardless of age and vaccination status, should receive at least one dose of oral polio vaccine before departure for Saudi Arabia. All travellers from these countries, regardless of age and previous immunization history, will also be required to receive an additional dose of oral polio vaccine upon arrival in Saudi Arabia [4,5].

Hepatitis B
Hepatitis B virus is found in body fluids and can be transmitted either through skin breakages or by close sexual contact. Transmission through the skin may occur through the use of contaminated medical, dental, or other instruments; all pilgrims should consider hepatitis B vaccine. One of the rites of Hajj is for men to have their head shaved. Although the Saudi authorities provide licensed barbers who use a new blade for each pilgrim, other barbers may not conform to such standards. Shaving with a previously used blade could carry a risk of hepatitis B and other bloodborne infections, and so communal use of a razor or blade to shave each other should be avoided. Pilgrims should consider taking with them a disposable razor for this purpose. This will also help to protect against hepatitis C virus infection [2].

Influenza
Recent studies have shown a high incidence of influenza infections during the Hajj [6,7,8], and so it would seem prudent to regard all Hajj pilgrims as at risk. The Ministry of Health of Saudi Arabia recommends that pilgrims be vaccinated against influenza before arrival, particularly those with pre-existing conditions (e.g. the elderly, people with chronic chest or heart diseases or those with cardiac, hepatic or renal failure) [4].

Vectorborne diseases


Yellow fever
All travellers arriving from countries endemic for yellow fever must present a valid yellow fever vaccination certificate in accordance with the International Health Regulations (http://www.who.int/csr/ihr/en/). These countries are listed by WHO [4]. In the absence of such a certificate, the person will be vaccinated upon arrival and placed under strict surveillance for 6 days from the day of vaccination or the last date of potential exposure to infection, whichever is earlier [4].

Saudi authorities also require that aircraft and other means of transportation arriving from areas infected with yellow fever are requested to submit a certificate indicating disinsection in accordance with the International Health Regulations.

Malaria
Malaria is not normally present in Medina or Mecca, but is a risk in other areas of Saudi Arabia including the south-western region and rural areas of the western region. Pilgrims may also plan further travel before or after Hajj to countries in Asia and Africa, and should seek advice about malaria prevention. Pilgrims are advised to practice insect bite avoidance measures that also protects against other vectorborne diseases [9].

References:

<!–[if !supportLists]–>1. <!–[endif]–>Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Ministry of Hajj. Hajj Visas. (http://www.hajinformation.com/main/t1510.htm)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>2. <!–[endif]–>Shafi S, Memish Z, Gatrad A, Sheikh A. Hajj 2006: communicable disease and other health risks and current official guidance for pilgrims. Euro Surveill 2005;10(12):E051215.2. (http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ew/2005/051215.asp#2)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>3. <!–[endif]–>Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Ministry of Hajj. Saudi Ministry of Health Requirements. (http://www.hajinformation.com/main/p3001.htm)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>4. <!–[endif]–>WHO. Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia for the pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj). Weekly Epidemiological Record 2006, 81(44), 417–424 (http://www.who.int/wer/2006/wer8144.pdf)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>5. <!–[endif]–>WHO. Health conditions for travellers to Saudi Arabia pilgrimage to Mecca (Hajj) III. Poliomyelitis. Weekly Epidemiological Record 2006; 81(46): 444 (http://www.who.int/wer/2006/wer8146.pdf)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>6. <!–[endif]–>Balkhy HH, Memish ZA, Bafaqeer S, Almuneef MA. Influenza a common viral infection among Hajj pilgrims: time for routine surveillance and vaccination. J Travel Med. 2004 Mar-Apr;11(2):82-6.

<!–[if !supportLists]–>7. <!–[endif]–>Shafi S, Rashid H, Ali K, El Bashir H, Zambon M, Haworth E, et al. Enhanced Surveillance of Influenza and other respiratory viruses among UK pilgrims to Hajj 2005. Presented at HPA Annual Conference; September 2005, Warwick, United Kingdom (Abstract available at http://www.iccuk.org/media/articles/misc/study_of_influenza.htm)

<!–[if !supportLists]–>8. <!–[endif]–>Haitham El Bashir, Elizabeth Haworth, Maria Zambon, Shuja Shafi, Jane Zuckerman, and Robert Booy.Influenza among U.K. Pilgrims to Hajj, 2003, Emerging Infectious diseases, 2004, 10, (10) 1883

<!–[if !supportLists]–>9. <!–[endif]–>NaTHNaC. Guidelines for Hajj Pilgrims. 24 November 2006. (http://www.nathnac.org/pro/clinical_updates/hajj241106.htm)

 

The influx of visitors from all over the world coupled with the crowded conditions during Hajj make the Hajj and Makkah an ideal environment to fuel an epidemic that pilgrims in turn could carry back to their own countries. Even the healthiest pilgrim may be susceptible to disease. It is also not uncommon for someone who has a life threatening condition or illness to purposely try to make it to Makkah (whether during Hajj or not) so he or she can have that last breath take place in Makkah. As a result, pilgrims should take precautions when visiting Makkah and the Haram. Wearing a face mask is recommended as well as ensuring all those inoculations are up-to-date.

About these ads

23 Responses

  1. Don’t forget this one: beware of stampedes.

  2. Inshallah, we will be going to Hajj this year…face masks on hand!
    And yes, Ryan…my biggest fear is a stampeed!

  3. What prompted me to write this post was most of my family members returned from Makkah this year after Eid al Fitr all sick with terrible bugs. It makes you wonder if it is a coincidence or not that a significant amount of time was spent in the Haram while there.

    In regards to Hajj, thankfully the Saudi authorities do have good crowd control.

  4. bedu- not a coincidence there are nasty little bugs that many pick up while in mekkah. it reaches to our relatives in Jeddah as well. Some the doctors just can’t figure out. And during school holidays you can expect that the families that go to Jeddah are going to bring some of those bugs back with them to school. it is a cycle we see all the time as many who live in the EP have a family base in Jeddah.

    I also fear getting run down during hajj. And for goodness sakes people LEAVE YOUR CHILDREN HOME. Way too many children get lost during hajj and they shouldn’t be there.

    pregnant women, STAY HOME Mekkah may seem like a wonderful plact to give birth but your putting your unborn at real risk.

  5. Hajj bugs are a fact of life for us Meccans. Last year was the *only* year I haven’t contracted something nasty because I hardly spent any time in Mecca last year (overseeing my move to Jeddah).

  6. UmmSumayah, there is a really good crowd control operation everywhere during Hajj. When you are in Mina, its not like what you see on TV from a helicopter camera. You can hardly feel the rush and crowd when you are inside. I was really amazed by that fact when I went for Hajj last year.

    Yes, always take care of small children.

    Some tips for those who are going for the stoning in Jamrah:
    * Always make sure that you decide with your group/spouse/family a spot where everyone can gather in case they get lost.
    * No matter how close you walk with everyone, everyone is bound to get loose.
    * The security personnels at the Jamrah will disperse-off large groups of people going for the stoning. This is because groups of people are the main cause of stamepdes, from earlier experiences.
    * ALWAYS act according to the orders of the security personnels and NOT what your group leader says.
    * Each group is assigned a certain time for the stoning. Make sure you go according to the time assigned for your group.

    May Allah accept your pilgrimage and make it easy for everyone.

  7. No, I wouldn’t say it’s the most deadly city. Not even close. It is reported that New Orleans is the most deadly city in America and one of the top 5 deadly in the world. I haven’t read any accounts that even remotely suggested that Mekkah was deadly.

  8. Lol. Good thing you are here to stand up for it then.

  9. Okay Ryan you managed TO MAKE ME LAUGH.

    btW THE REASON NWHY I ASSUMED U WERE UNBELIEVER IS BECAUSE THE FIRST TIME UNBELIEVER POSTED ON MY BLOG WAS TO A RESPONSE I WROTE TO U WHERE U ACTUALLY REFERRED TO YOUR SELF AS A KAFIR/UNBELIEVE/DISBELIEVER …FOR GET WHICH ONE. I THOUGHT IT WAS U JUST BEING CHEEKY. I DO SEE THE DIFFERENT PERSONALITY AND THOUGHT MAYBE U HAD JUST UNLEASHED YOUR ALTER EGO. I’M NOT YELLING MY BABY IS KICKING THE KEYS AND NOW THAT I REALIZED I JUST TYPED IN ALL CAPS IT’S TOO MUCH TO go back and redo. as my children would say, “pardon me”.

  10. Unleashing my alter ego. Lol! I wonder what my alter ego would be like.

  11. More curiosity: I wonder what your altar ego would be like?!!

  12. [No, I wouldn’t say it’s the most deadly city. Not even close....]

    Ok we get it. saudi arabia is perfect.

  13. Salaams Carol:

    My husband went to Hajj in 2007, Alhamdulillah; he went with a group and it went off perfectly!

    However, he came home very ill. He never gets sick and he was so ill that I was really afraid. It lasted about a month.

    I think it’s normal when you have that many people in one place from all over the world that people get sick due to lack of immunity. I worked in a hospital once where people came to us from all over the eastern seaboard USA. Every new employee really suffered during their first year of employment.

  14. Abid, do I detect a little animosity in your tone? Carol asked the question in her subject line if Makkah is The Most Holiest (sacred would me more appropriate) and also mostdeadly city. I merely answered the question. I never said Saudi was perfect I answered her question.

  15. I am visiting with family in Makkah for a week now . It only took 2 days to catch a nasty bug and that is after taking the flu shot before coming. Like Saudi Jawa said, it comes with the territory.

  16. Sorry to hear that Saudi in US and hope that you are feeling better now!!

  17. Such control systems is really needed because many Muslims would want to visit Makkah at least once in their lifetimes and we have more than 1 billion Muslims whereas Makkah can contain only so much.

    Just like Citibank’s slogan, Makkah never sleeps. At all.

  18. I have been hearing from family members who live in Makkah that even Makkah is feeling the impact of the global financial crisis. There are not as many pilgrims for hajj and after the wild flurry of activity to build more buildings and establish more furnished apartments for pilgrims, many are setting empty and unrented.

  19. Mecca is my favorite holiest city in the world…. insha allah i’ll come few days……… Aameen.

  20. @Mydeen,

    Salam Alaikum. Insha’allah you will have the opportunity to arrive soon.

  21. here i read the post which is very breifly written INSHA ALLAH very soon i will be in Saudi Arabia for performing Hajj, i have perform umra last year

  22. No-doubt it’s the most holy but not the most deadly by any means, at-least I can’t find it here “Top 10 most deadly cities in the World”

    http://urbantitan.com/10-most-dangerous-cities-in-the-world-in-2011/

    The spirit of all Muslims should never be shaken due to the negative hype created by any sources let be Muslim or non-Muslim. It’s a compulsion for all Muslims to perform Hajj and we all should do it if we have the financial resources.

  23. [...] to the number of pilgrims coming to the Kingdom from all over the world, there is also a concern of disease or illness.  Each pilgrim must undergo a medical examination and have certain inoculations prior to arrival [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,129 other followers

%d bloggers like this: